• Home
  • About
  • Books
  • Events
  • Editorial Services
  • Substack
  • Contact
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Substack
    • YouTube

Sara Ella

April 27, 2013

A Plain Scandal by Amanda Flower ~ Review and Giveaway

plain

Purchase your copy here

Chloe Humphrey has a mystery on her hands, one that is affecting the Amish community of Appleseed Creek more than anyone expected. Who is responsible for cutting the hair of several young Amish girls? Is this crime linked to one that’s far worse and much more shocking?

A Plain Scandal, Book Two in Amanda Flower’s Appleseed Creek Mystery Series, will give you a serious case of the “Who-Dunnits?” Full of mystery, humor, and even a bit of romance, this book would make great addition to your summer reading list.

 What I liked…

Amish fiction is a new genre I’ve begun to explore over the last year. So far, I’ve really enjoyed everything I’ve come across and A Plain Scandal is no different. It’s part of a series, but works as a stand-alone title as well. Amanda Flower’s take on Amish fiction was refreshing and unique. By making it an Amish mystery, I thought she offered something new and different. I got a slice of Amish culture but also got the chance to look through the eyes of an outsider via the book’s protagonist, Chloe.

Chloe is the “Nancy Drew” of the book, if you will. Each chapter left me with questions, and I needed the answers. I was drawn into the mystery of the story while also becoming involved with the characters along the way. Reading A Plain Scandal made me want to go back and read Book One, A Plain Death, as well as continue on with the series with Book Three, A Plain Disappearance, which releases in September 2013.

 Recommendation…

A Plain Scandal is Amish fiction with a twist. For those mystery lovers out there who haven’t been drawn to the Amish genre before, this book may just be your hook. I quite enjoyed this book. If you liked the Nancy Drew or Mandy mysteries as a kid, you’ll enjoy A Plain Scandal as an adult.

 An Interview with Amanda Flower

1. A Plain Scandal is a mystery set in the Appleseed Creek Amish Community. What is it that drew you to write novels with an Amish setting? Was there a lot of research involved beforehand?

When I was twenty-four and just graduated from graduate school, I looked all over the country for a librarian job. The only offer I got was for a small college in the middle of Ohio’s Amish Country. I lived there for three years near the Amish. At the time, I didn’t think much of it, but later, I realized what a unique experience I had had and that it would be a great basis for a mystery. For the series, even though I had friends with close Amish connections, I researched a lot because I’m a librarian and I enjoy it. Much of my research never makes it into a book.

2. A Plain Scandal is the second in a series. How do you plan and prepare for series writing? How is it easier/ more difficult than writing a stand alone title? What advice can you offer to writers who aspire to be series authors?

I’ve always been a series writer because that’s what I like to read. I love to see how characters will develop over multiple books. With series, I can take my time, especially in the case of the romantic story line because I know I have several books to draw it out over.

For those who aspire to be series writers, I would say create amazing characters that a reader will want to revisit again and again.

3. This series is unique in that it is a mystery/suspense series as well. What are some elements you believe are needed to create a good mystery? Is it more difficult to write a mystery rather than your typical inspirational story? Why or why not?

Every novel I’ve written, even those for children, have been mysteries. I’ve never tried my hand at another genre, but I imagine it would be difficult for me because in my mysteries the crime solving drives the main plot. As a mystery author, I know the bad guy will (usually) get caught in the end. A good mystery surprises readers and has just enough clues for the ending to make sense.

4. The protagonist, Chloe Humphrey, is really a modern day Nancy Drew. She has a knack for solving mystery, and she isn’t afraid to put her nose where it doesn’t belong if it means digging up the truth. How much of your own personality can readers expect to find in Miss Humphrey? What about crime solving appeals most to you?

I like mysteries because I like puzzles and problem solving, so does Chloe. Other than that, Chloe and I are very different. She is much braver than I am. I wouldn’t try to solve a murder; I’d leave it up to the police.

5. A Plain Scandal also has a touch of romance. What is the most romantic thing anyone has ever done for you? How do you draw from real life experiences to make your stories more authentic?

Goodness. That’s a tough one for me. I think the little things couples do for each other are the most romantic or the inside jokes they share.

6. Is there a verse or scripture passage that has helped or encouraged you in your writing? If so, what is it and how has it impacted you?

Psalm 37:4 is my verse for my writing life. “Delight yourself in the Lord, and he will give you the desires of your heart.” It took me nine years to get published, which was my heart’s desire; I fell back on that verse a lot.

7. When did you know that writing was the career for you? What would you say to aspiring authors who are feeling discouraged in their pursuit of a writing career?

When I was in grade school, I read a humorous story I wrote to my class and they laughed. That’s when I knew I wanted to be a writer. My advice to any aspiring writer is don’t give up. There are many obstacles to a writer’s life, but you have keeping going and keep writing. Eventually, you will break through and get that contract.

About Amanda Flower…

FlowerAmanda Flower found her call to write in sixth grade.  She read a story she wrote about being stuck on the top of a Ferris wheel, putting her whole class in stitches, and it was at that moment she’d found her calling of making people laugh with her words. Her debut mystery, Maid of Murder, was an Agatha Award Nominee for Best First Novel. Amanda is an academic librarian for a small college near Cleveland. She also writes mysteries as Isabella Alan. You can learn more about Amanda Flower by visiting her website at AmandaFlower.com or by connecting with her on Facebook and Twitter.

Disclosure:

I received an EBook copy of A Plain Scandal from Shelton Interactive. I was not asked to write a positive review. All views and opinions expressed are solely and completely my own. I received no compensation other than a digital copy of A Plain Scandal, which is mine to keep. This post also contains affiliate links. To learn more, please see my full policy.

 

Copyright © 2013 SaraElla.com


Share this:

  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook

Like this:

Like Loading...

3 Comments

« Review ~ Swept Away by Mary Connealy
My Princess Bible Purse ~ Review Plus Giveaway »

Comments

  1. Carolyn says

    April 27, 2013 at 12:51 pm

    I need a good book to read for the summer. This sounds like a good one!

    Reply
  2. Maryann says

    April 27, 2013 at 1:53 pm

    I like that Amish Fiction is clean good reading. I love reading all the character and family stories

    Reply
    • Sara Ella says

      April 27, 2013 at 2:31 pm

      Me too, Mary Ann! I like to collect books that I know my girls can read one day too:)

      Reply

Leave a ReplyCancel reply

Click to add to Goodreads!

Click to add to Goodreads!

Subscribe on YouTube!

Subscribe on YouTube!

Check out my Novel’s Pinterest Board & Follow Me!

Sara Ella
Follow Sara Ella's board Blemished on Pinterest.

1st Place ~ ACFW Genesis Contest 2014 ~ YA Category

1st Place ~ ACFW Genesis Contest 2014 ~ YA Category

1st Place in the Young Adult Category for 2013!

e1366654719

About Me

Once upon a time, Sara Ella brought dreams to life as a Disney cast member, wishing for the day she’d find her prince and live in a castle of her own. Now she spends her days homeschooling her three Jedi in training, braving the Arizona summers, and reminding her superhero husband that it's almost Christmas (even if it's only January). Sara is the award-winning author of The Wonderland Trials, Coral, and the Unblemished trilogy. She is old enough for fairy tales and believes happily ever after is never far away. Read More…

Subscribe to Ever After in Progress

Join my newsletter for updates, writing tips, and behind-the-scenes from my author life.

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Latest on Instagram

🗓️ MARK YOUR CALENDARS! I have a full lineup of b 🗓️ MARK YOUR CALENDARS!

I have a full lineup of bookish events this spring! I’d love to see you at one or all of these:

@storyconusa | Salt Lake City, UT | February 27 & 28 | Workshops + Interrogate an Author + Book Signings

@tucsonfestivalofbooks | Saturday, March 14 | 10:00–1:00 | Indie Author Pavillion 

@pvpllibrary Book Fest | Saturday,
May 2 | Workshop + Panel + Book Signing

#saraella #saraellawrites #enclavepublishing #storycon #tucsonfestivalofbooks
🍪 Food is my love language. Whenever we go out of 🍪 Food is my love language.

Whenever we go out of town, I’m already looking at menus ahead of time, planning what yummy things I want to eat.

Themed food is my favorite. Call a honey latte a Pooh Bear Latte and I’m sold! Serve me a cup of the most delectable potato soup I’ve ever had and call it Samwise Soup? I’m there! 

If I’m going to Disneyland, I’m planning my day around which new cold brew I want to try and where I want to eat lunch. And if I’m going to a writing conference? You’d better bet I’m on the hunt for a Vanilla Coke and the best hotel cookies yet!

Yummy food just makes everything a little more magical. Can you relate? What’s your favorite food, drink, or dessert?

#favoritecharacter #favoritecharacters #funnyreels #onlyhereforthefood #bookcharacter
🥳 Happy Birthday, @nadinebrandes ! There aren’t m 🥳 Happy Birthday, @nadinebrandes !

There aren’t many people in this world who tackle hardship with joy the way you do. You are a true example of what it means to “count it all joy” amidst trials. Even on your toughest days, you find ways to bless others and see God’s sovereignty.

I don’t know what I did to deserve you as my best friend all these years. But I do know that God brought you into my life because He knew my life would be richer and fuller and just all around better with you in it. He knew I would need someone to walk alongside me in good times and bad. Someone to encourage me during discouraging years like this one has been.

I have been so blessed to see you so much in 2025. Although we are states apart, when we are together it feels like no time has passed at all.

Here’s to the woman who inspires me as an author, speaks truth into me as a wife and mom, and reminds me that God never leaves us and that His plan and timing are perfect. I love you, Bestie! Many happy returns for the rest of 2025 and the year to come! My life is better because I know you.

#nadinebrandes #saraella #bestfriends
You know I’m always behind on the trends, but I co You know I’m always behind on the trends, but I couldn’t resist doing this one for Disneyland. 

I’m definitely dreaming of a Disneyland Christmas this year. 🎄 If anyone knows of someone giving away free tickets for a family of 5, send them my way! 😂

Fun fact about this date: December 18, 1971 was the first ever Candlelight Processional held at Magic Kingdom. 🕯️

I’m dreaming of more Disney days in 2026. Christmas is my favorite season to visit the parks. They are just extra magical this time of year. ✨

Are you staying home or traveling for Christmas this year? 

#disneylandchristmas #dreamingofdisneyland #disneylandpark #disneylandcalifornia
🚫GIVEAWAY CLOSED! The winner is @the_disney_reader 🚫GIVEAWAY CLOSED! The winner is @the_disney_reader ! 🎉

🎄CHRISTMAS PAINTED EDGES GIVEAWAY! 

Did you see my unboxing reel for the painted edges of Glass Across the Sea? These editions are extremely limited as they are hand-painted by the very talented @hilltop_art . 🎨

For Christmas, I’m giving away one of these painted edges editions, plus a bookish Glass Across the Sea candle 🕯️ from @lamplighterliterary and mini cookie mix from @story.crumbs ! 🍪

Today is the LAST DAY to enter this giveaway. I’ll be putting all entries together tomorrow and sending them through a randomizer to pick a winner!

Entry rules and details are all in the caption of my unboxing reel. Enter there to win this dreamy Christmas gift! 🎁 

#paintededges #paintedbooks #handpainted #paintededgesbook #handpaintedbooks #christmasbookgiveaway #bookgiveaway #christmasgiveaway
🚫GIVEAWAY CLOSED! The winner is @the_disney_reader 🚫GIVEAWAY CLOSED! The winner is @the_disney_reader ! 🎉

🎨 Painted Edges Unboxing & GIVEAWAY 🎁

I’m so thrilled to finally be holding these beautiful painted edges for Glass Across the Sea in my hands. Bethany @hilltop_art made my vision for the most beautiful lighthouse come to life! And the details are even more stunning in person. From the lighthouse to the fireflies and cherry blossoms, I couldn’t be more in love!

I want to give one of these gorgeous limited editions away for Christmas, along with some other goodies! 🎄

🎁 One U.S. winner will receive:

📖 A hardcover of Glass Across the Sea with Painted Edges

🕯️A Prince Dante candle created by @lamplighterliterary 

🍪A mini Noelle cookie mix created by @story.crumbs 

✅ To Enter the giveaway:

➡️ Follow @saraellawrites and @hilltop_art 

❤️ Like this Reel

💬 Comment & tag a friend who might love this giveaway too

↗️ Share this Reel to your stories and tag me @saraellawrites for a BONUS entry

🏷️ Save this Reel for a BONUS Entry

Enter to win through Monday, December 8th at 11:59 p.m. PST. U.S. Only. Instagram only. Winner will be announced Tuesday, December 9th and tagged in my stories and on this Reel. Winner will be contacted via direct message for shipping address from this account only. Void where prohibited. Prize will be mailed in time to arrive by Christmas.

#saraella #glassacrossthesea #yafantasy #cinderellaretelling #paintededges #paintededgesbook #bookgiveaway #winabook #christmasgiveaway #christmasgiveaways
✍️ When did you first start writing? This is a c ✍️ When did you first start writing? 

This is a common question I’ve received in various settings over the years. The easy answer is, “I’ve always been a writer.” And it’s true. English was my favorite subject all through school, and I’ve never not loved reading.

But when did I actually start taking novel writing seriously? When did I really begin believing that I could pursue it and reach my dreams of having a published book in my hands?

That happened in my 20s. When I had a baby on my hip, and my mom’s health began to rapidly decline. She’d always said I was a writer. It’s why my first book, Unblemished, is dedicated to her. But the truth goes deeper than that.

My mom’s lifelong dream was to open a coffee shop. I suppose it’s part of why I love this beverage more than any other. She wanted to create a place where people could fellowship, eat, laugh, and, of course, drink all the yummy coffee. But she passed away before that dream became a reality. 

She had always put off her own dreams for us kids. She sacrificed everything for us. As a mom of 3, what she did for us holds so much more meaning now. But she didn’t want me to wait. She said I could do both. That if I put off writing a book until I had time or my kids were grown, I never would.

I don’t know if that’s true. Lots of people write books later in life and are highly successful. But her hope for my future stuck with me, and so, after she passed, I made a promise to myself that I would write a book and get a publishing contract by my 30th birthday.

Many of you know the story—3 days before my 30th, I got the call. My dream publisher at the time wanted my trilogy. 🥹 And the rest is history!

Now I have 7 YA fantasy and fairy tale novels on the shelf, I have the most amazing family at @enclavepublishing , and I’m blessed with encouraging readers and writers all around me.

If you’re holding back from pursuing the thing you are passionate about, I’d encourage you to go for it.  Take the leap! My mom always said I’d write a book, and as always, she was right. ❤️

#writeabook #ihaveadream #timecastaspellonyou #writerswrite #authorsofinstagram📚 #authorcommunity #listentoyourmom #enclavepublishing
🎧 Do audiobook narrators make or break a story for 🎧 Do audiobook narrators make or break a story for you? 

I’ll admit, I am very selective when it comes to the audiobooks I listen to, and probably even more picky regarding the narrators for my own books.

I am so thankful to @enclavepublishing and @oasis_audio for how involved they have let me be in the audiobook process. @megrunyannarration and @ramondeocampo knocked Glass Across the Sea out of the park! They worked so hard to bring this fairy tale world to life in such a magical and enchanting way. 🥰

Glass Across the Sea is available to download on audiobook now. And @audible even has a Cyber Monday deal today—3 months of Audible PLUS a $20 Audible credit for $0.99 a month! ✨LINK in STORIES✨ Today, December 1st, only!

Shoutout to @charmagnebooklover for sending me a glass pumpkin!

#glassacrossthesea #audiobook #audiobooknarration #bestaudiobook #bestaudiobooknarrators #ramondeocampo #megrunyan #oasisaudio #enclavepublishing #yafantasybooks #yacleanromance #yafairytale #cinderella
🩷 Happy Small Business Saturday! When I first sta 🩷 Happy Small Business Saturday!

When I first started out on my writing and publishing journey, I never imagined my idea for a portal fantasy about a girl afraid to look in the mirror would lead to a decade of books, editing clients, mentees, and more.

I am truly grateful for every single manuscript I’ve had the privilege to edit. For every author I’ve mentored who has equally blessed me with encouragement and kindness. And this year especially, for every reader who took a chance by picking up Glass Across the Sea, and every Substack subscriber who has followed me on my new venture.

This year has ushered in many ups and downs. I’ve never seen so much grief and loss in the span of twelve months. I don’t know what the future holds for our family. I don’t know where God will have us in 2026. Every day brings its own struggles.

But I do know I am so grateful for each person who has blessed and supported my little writing and editing business in different ways. You have made a greater impact on me and my family than you know. And for that I’m humbled and thankful.

👉 Tag your favorite small business in the comments so we can spread the support and follow them! Some of mine include:

@mariposa.aristeo.art 
@jennethleed 
@writewithapro 
@nadinebrandes 
@enclavepublishing 
@cassieporathauthor 
@gracebought 
@music.with.noelle 
@eahcreative 
@hannahprewettstories 
@hilltop_art 
@zoeshaffer_art 
@ms.madeleine.elizabeth 
@crystalgrantauthor 
@erinmcfarlandaz 
@story.crumbs 
@yourebakingmehappy 
@lamplighterliterary 

#smallbusinesssaturday #smallbusiness #smallbusinessowner #supportsmallbusiness #saraella #saraellawrites
Follow on Instagram

 

 

© 2026 Sara Ella
 

Loading Comments...
 

    %d